Refunds, e-verification, notices and corrections · Tax Year 2025-26
Defective return notice u/s 139(9): how to fix it
A section 139(9) notice says your return has a defect. See what causes it, how long the portal gives you, how to correct it with Agree or Disagree, and what can happen if the defect is not fixed.
On this page
A defective return notice (section 139(9)) means the department thinks something in the return you filed is incomplete or inconsistent, and asks you to fix it. Reply on the e-Filing portal within the time the notice gives; the portal's help page says this is 15 days from receiving it unless your notice states another period. This guide is for a return of tax year 2025-26 (AY 2026-27 on the portal), under the Income-tax Act, 1961.
In short
- The notice is sent to your registered email, and you can also see it after logging in to the portal.
- You answer under Pending Actions > e-Proceedings by choosing Agree or Disagree for each defect.
- The portal says a submitted response cannot be updated or withdrawn.
- If the defect is not cured, the return may be treated as invalid, as if it was not filed correctly.
- If you are unsure how to correct the return, ask a Tax Expert before you submit.
What counts as a defect
The portal's FAQ says a return may be treated as defective on account of incomplete or inconsistent information. It lists these examples:
Example of defect | Plain meaning |
|---|---|
TDS credit claimed without the related income offered to tax | You took credit for tax deducted but did not report the income it relates to |
Gross receipts in Form 26AS higher than receipts reported under all heads | The department sees more receipts than your return shows |
Gross total income shown as nil although tax was computed and paid | The figures in the return do not agree with each other |
Name in the ITR differs from the PAN database | The name does not match the PAN record |
Business or professional income reported without a balance sheet and profit and loss account | Required statements are missing |
Step by step
- Log in to the e-Filing portal and open Pending Actions > e-Proceedings.
- Click View Notice for the section 139(9) notice and read each defect listed.
- Click Submit Response. For each defect choose Agree or Disagree.
- If you agree, the portal asks for the mode of response, the ITR type, and the corrected return as a JSON file (an offline correction). The corrected return is prepared in the ITR utility or software.
- If you disagree, you must write the reason for disagreeing.
- Submit. A success message shows a transaction ID and a confirmation email goes to your registered address. Note the transaction ID.
You can also authorise another person, such as a Tax Expert, to respond for you.
Revised return or response?
If the time for filing a fresh or revised return for that year is still open, you may submit a revised return (section 139(5)). Once that time has closed, the portal says you will have to respond to the notice instead. For the windows that apply to your year, see belated, revised or updated return.
Worked example (hypothetical)
Meera (invented) files ITR-1 and claims TDS of ₹8,000 from a bank. Her return shows no interest income. Form 26AS shows bank interest of ₹90,000 with that TDS. A defect notice arrives saying TDS credit is claimed without the related income. Meera reads the notice and checks Form 26AS: the interest is hers and she forgot to report it. She chooses Agree, prepares the corrected return with the ₹90,000 of interest, uploads the JSON file, submits, and notes the transaction ID. Had the 26AS entry been someone else's, she would choose Disagree and write why, with proof. (The amounts are invented to show the steps; they are not a tax computation.)
If you do not respond
The portal says the return may be treated as invalid, and that consequences may include penalty, interest, the loss of the right to carry forward losses and the loss of specific exemptions, as per the Income Tax Act. A return that cannot be corrected is treated as invalid or not filed for that year.
Common mistakes
- Choosing Agree without uploading the correct JSON, or uploading the old return again.
- Disagreeing without a clear reason or proof.
- Waiting for the email: also check Pending Actions on the portal.
- Assuming a response can be edited later. It cannot be withdrawn once submitted.
- Filing a new return that repeats the same defect.
When a Tax Expert is sensible
If the defect involves business statements, TDS you do not recognise, or a change of ITR form, a Tax Expert can read your notice and prepare the correction. Reply within the notice's time whoever helps you.
Related guides: Wrong ITR form filed: what to do, e-Proceedings and pending actions, income tax notices after filing. Try the income tax calculator to re-check your figures.
This guide gives general information and is not legal or professional tax advice.
Questions on this topic
How long do I have to respond to a 139(9) notice?
The portal says 15 days from receiving the notice, or the period stated in the notice. You may seek an adjournment to ask for an extension. Always follow the date in your own notice.
Can I file a revised return instead of responding?
Only while the time for filing a fresh or revised return for that year is still open. Once it has closed, the portal says you have to respond to the notice.
Can I change my response after submitting it?
No. The portal says a response cannot be updated or withdrawn once submitted, so check it first.
What if I do not respond?
The portal says the return may be treated as invalid, which may bring penalty, interest, loss of the right to carry forward losses and loss of specific exemptions.
Is a defective return notice the same as a tax demand?
No. It asks you to correct the return. It is not a demand for money, but an uncorrected return may be treated as invalid.
Ready to file your ITR?
TaxCare fetches your AIS and TDS from the Income Tax portal, checks every figure and files the return that saves you the most. 25% off your first filing.