Skip to content
TaxCare

Armed forces ITR: wrong claims and how to fix them

Service allowances, disability pension and Agniveer deductions are easy to get wrong. Hypothetical examples show the common claim mistakes, what the department does next, and how to correct a return.

On this page

Service pay slips carry many allowances, and their tax rules are scattered across several sections and a long rule. It is easy to claim an allowance as exempt when it is not, to use the wrong year's limit, or to claim a deduction twice. This guide uses hypothetical examples to show the common mistakes, what the Income Tax Department does next, and how to put them right. It is about the return for tax year 2025-26 (the return filed in 2026, shown on the portal as AY 2026-27), which is still governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961.

In short

  • Only allowances named in Rule 2BB are exempt, each up to a monthly limit, and almost all of them only in the old regime.
  • The much higher limits in the Income-tax Rules, 2026 (₹42,500 Siachen, ₹22,000 counter-insurgency and others) start from tax year 2026-27. They do not apply to tax year 2025-26.
  • A wrong claim visible in the return can be adjusted at processing, after a communication giving you 30 days to respond. A penalty can follow an assessment: under the Income-tax Act, 2025, 50% of the tax on under-reported income, or 200% where it comes from misreporting (the 1961 Act rates are reported to be the same).
  • You can correct a mistake yourself: a revised return until 31-Mar-2027, or an updated return (ITR-U) later, paying the tax with interest.
  • Keep pay slips, posting orders, rent proof, the pension payment order and medical board records for every exempt amount you claim.

Nothing here describes any real person or suggests that service personnel make these mistakes more than anyone else. Most errors come from confusing rules, and the same rules apply to every taxpayer.

What happens when a claim is wrong

At processing. The department can adjust an incorrect claim that is apparent from information in the return. Before it does, you get a communication and 30 days to respond. The resulting intimation is treated as a notice of demand. If the intimation itself has a mistake apparent from the record, you can ask for rectification (section 154 of the 1961 Act, section 287 of the 2025 Act).

At assessment. A claim can also be examined in a faceless assessment (section 144B; section 273 of the 2025 Act) or after a reassessment notice (section 148; section 280 of the 2025 Act). An adjustment at processing alone is not under-reported income for penalty purposes; an assessment that raises income above the processed figure is.

Your data. For tax year 2025-26 the department's statements are Form 26AS and the Annual Information Statement (AIS). From tax year 2026-27 the annual statement is Form 168.

Penalties, interest and immunity

Item

Rule

Under-reporting

Penalty of 50% of the tax payable on the under-reported income (s.439(9) of the 2025 Act; the same 50% under s.270A of the 1961 Act is reported).

Misreporting

200% of that tax where the under-reporting comes from misreporting, for example misrepresentation or suppression of facts, or a claim of expenditure not supported by any evidence (s.439(10)-(11); the 200% under s.270A is reported).

No penalty

Where the explanation is found bona fide and all material facts were disclosed (s.439(8)(a); same rule reported under s.270A(6)(a)).

Interest

Late return 1% a month (s.234A; s.423 of the 2025 Act), plus interest for advance-tax shortfall and deferment (ss.234B and 234C; ss.424 and 425 of the 2025 Act).

Immunity, tax year 2025-26 and earlier

Section 270AA as substituted from 1-Mar-2026: apply within one month from the end of the month in which the order is received, pay the tax and interest within the demand period, file no appeal; in a misreporting case, also pay additional income-tax of 100% of the tax on under-reported income instead of the penalty. It covers the penalty and prosecution under ss.276C and 276CC, but not where those proceedings have already started.

Immunity, tax year 2026-27 onward

Section 440 of the 2025 Act: the same conditions; additional income-tax of 100% (misreporting) or 120% (unexplained income).

Penalty timing

For assessments made on or after 1-Apr-2027, the penalty is imposed in the assessment order itself, after a show-cause notice.

Prosecution provisions deal with wilful attempts to evade tax. Under the 1961 Act it is section 276C (this guide does not quote its terms). From tax year 2026-27, section 478 of the 2025 Act provides simple imprisonment up to 2 years and/or a fine where the tax evaded is more than ₹50 lakh, up to 6 months and/or a fine where it is more than ₹10 lakh, and a fine only below that. A false statement in the verification of a return is a separate offence (s.277; s.482 of the 2025 Act).

How to correct a mistake yourself

  • Revised return: for tax year 2025-26, until 31-Mar-2027, or until the assessment is completed if that is earlier. A revision filed after 31-Dec-2026 carries a fee of ₹5,000, or ₹1,000 if total income is up to ₹5 lakh.
  • Updated return (ITR-U): up to 48 months from the end of the year following the tax year (for tax year 2025-26, that year ends on 31-Mar-2027). It cannot reduce tax or raise a refund. You pay additional tax of 25%, 50%, 60% or 70% of the tax and interest, depending on whether it is filed in the first, second, third or fourth year; a further 10% applies if it is filed after a reassessment notice within that notice's period. From 1-Mar-2026, income on which this additional tax is paid cannot be the basis of a penalty under section 270A.
  • Pay first: work out the extra tax and interest and pay it as self-assessment tax before you file the corrected return.

Eleven hypothetical mistakes

In each example the people and numbers are invented. Unless stated, it is tax year 2025-26, the old regime, and the extra income is taxed at an illustrative 31.2% (30% slab plus 4% cess) only to show the size of a penalty. A real penalty is computed on the "tax payable on under-reported income" under the Act's own formula, not this shortcut.

1. HRA for months spent in government quarters

  • Claim. Major A (hypothetical) claims HRA exemption of ₹1,80,000 for 12 months, but lived in government quarters for 7 of them and paid no rent.
  • Why it fails. HRA is exempt only where you actually pay rent for the house you live in.
  • Consequence. The 7 months' share, ₹1,05,000, is taxable: tax ₹32,760 at the illustrative rate. A 50% penalty would be ₹16,380. If rent receipts that are not genuine were used, it is misrepresentation, and 200% would be ₹65,520.
  • Fix. Claim HRA only for months of genuine rented housing; revise or file ITR-U.

2. Using the 2026-27 Siachen limit in the 2025-26 return

  • Claim. Havildar B (hypothetical), in the old regime, receives ₹42,500 a month as Siachen allowance and shows it all as exempt.
  • Why it fails. For tax year 2025-26 the Rule 2BB limit is ₹7,000 a month. ₹42,500 is the limit in the Income-tax Rules, 2026, for tax year 2026-27 onward.
  • Consequence. ₹35,500 × 12 = ₹4,26,000 is under-reported. Illustrative tax ₹1,32,912; 50% penalty ₹66,456; 200% (if misreported) ₹2,65,824.
  • Fix. Exempt only ₹84,000 (₹7,000 × 12).

3. Field area and border area for the same months

  • Claim. Captain C (hypothetical) claims the Compensatory Field Area Allowance (₹2,600 limit) and, for the same 10 months, a border-area allowance of ₹1,300 a month.
  • Why it fails. A person claiming the field area (or modified field area) allowance cannot also claim the border, remote or disturbed-area allowance.
  • Consequence. ₹13,000 is disallowed: illustrative tax ₹4,056, and a 50% penalty of ₹2,028 if it is raised at assessment rather than adjusted at processing.
  • Fix. Claim the one allowance the rules allow for those months.

4. Every pay-slip allowance entered as exempt under section 10(14)

  • Claim. Lieutenant D (hypothetical) enters ₹2,40,000 of MSP, group pay and flying allowance as "exempt under section 10(14)".
  • Why it fails. Only allowances named in Rule 2BB are exempt, each to its monthly limit. MSP, X/Y group pay, and flying, sea-going, submarine, diving and parachute allowances are not named, so they are taxable salary. An allowance for duties of a special nature is not exempt unless it relates to the place of posting or residence.
  • Consequence. The e-filing utility only checks the total against "Other allowance", so the claim may go through, but it is an incorrect claim: illustrative tax ₹74,880, 50% penalty ₹37,440.
  • Fix. Match each exempt amount to a Rule 2BB row and its monthly cap; the rest is salary.

5. Service allowances claimed in the new regime

  • Claim. Counter-insurgency, high-altitude and uniform allowances claimed as exempt while filing in the new regime.
  • Why it fails. In the new regime for 2025-26 only the tour/transfer travel, daily charges and conveyance allowances (Rule 2BB(1)(a)-(c)) and the transport allowance for an employee with a specified disability stay exempt. All other Rule 2BB allowances are taxable.
  • Consequence. The utility rejects the claim.
  • Fix. Compare both regimes; if the allowances matter, choose the old regime.

6. Disability pension without the record behind it

  • Claim. Colonel E (retired, hypothetical) retired on superannuation, has no service-attributable disability on record, and shows his pension as exempt "Defence Medical Disability Pension".
  • Why it fails. For tax year 2025-26 the exemption rests on CBDT instructions, not a section. As reported in an ITAT order, CBDT Circular 13/2019 limited it to personnel invalided out, and the Supreme Court ordered status quo. None of that turns an ordinary pension into a disability pension. From tax year 2026-27, a new entry (Schedule III Sl.38A) exempts it where the member was invalided out for a disability attributable to or aggravated by service and did not retire on superannuation or otherwise; those conditions apply from a date the Central Government notifies, and until then the entire disability pension of a disabled officer is exempt.
  • Consequence. If the exemption does not apply, the pension is taxable salary and the exemption claimed is under-reported income.
  • Fix. Claim under "DMD" only what the pension payment order shows as disability pension, backed by the medical board record.

7. Agniveer: Corpus Fund contributions counted wrongly

  • Claim. Agniveer F (hypothetical) deducts the Government's contribution under section 80CCH(2) without first adding it to salary, or deducts his own contribution twice, under 80CCH(1) and again under 80C. In the new regime he also claims 80CCH(1).
  • Why it fails. The Government's contribution is salary first (entered in the return as salary item 17, "Contribution made by the central government towards Agnipath scheme"); 80CCH(2) then deducts it, in both regimes. 80CCH(1) covers his own contribution, once, in the old regime only. The same payment cannot be deducted twice.
  • Consequence. Income is understated by the double-counted amount: disallowance, and a possible penalty for under-reporting. The utility rejects 80CCH(1) in the new regime.
  • Fix. Add item 17 to salary; deduct the Government share once under 80CCH(2) and, in the old regime, your own share once under 80CCH(1). The Seva Nidhi paid on exit is fully exempt under section 10(12C).

8. Section 80C for a premium never paid

  • Claim. Naik G (hypothetical) claims ₹1,50,000 under 80C, of which ₹40,000 is a policy premium not paid that year.
  • Why it fails. 80C allows sums actually paid in the year, within the ₹1,50,000 cap shared with 80CCC and 80CCD(1).
  • Consequence. ₹40,000 under-reported: illustrative tax ₹12,480; 50% penalty ₹6,240; with fabricated proof, 200% ₹24,960.
  • Fix. Claim only what you paid, and keep the receipts.

9. Leave encashed while still serving

  • Claim. Commander H (hypothetical) encashes 60 days' leave while serving, ₹2,00,000, and shows it as exempt under section 10(10AA).
  • Why it fails. The Government employee's exemption is for leave encashed at retirement.
  • Consequence. ₹2,00,000 is taxable: illustrative tax ₹62,400; 50% penalty ₹31,200.
  • Fix. Show it as salary.

10. Re-employed, but the pension left out

  • Claim. Subedar J (retired, hypothetical) now works for a bank and reports only the new salary, leaving out a defence pension of ₹4,00,000.
  • Why it fails. Pension is taxable as salary; both incomes belong in the return. The standard deduction is capped at ₹50,000 (old regime) or ₹75,000 (new regime), and is reported to be one deduction in total, not one per payer.
  • Consequence. ₹4,00,000 under-reported: illustrative tax ₹1,24,800; 50% penalty ₹62,400. The pension payer's data can reach Form 26AS/AIS.
  • Fix. Show both under Salary with one standard deduction; pay any balance as self-assessment tax before filing.

11. Family pension shown as exempt when the death was not in operational duty

  • Claim. Mrs K (hypothetical), whose husband died of an illness at home, shows a family pension of ₹3,00,000 as exempt under section 10(19).
  • Why it fails. Section 10(19) needs a death in operational duties (such as enemy action, action against extremists, a peacekeeping mission abroad or mine clearance), certified by the Head of Department or service headquarters.
  • Consequence. The family pension is taxable as income from other sources, so the exemption claimed is under-reported income.
  • Fix. Show it under other sources and deduct the lower of one-third and ₹15,000 (old regime: taxable ₹2,85,000) or ₹25,000 (new regime: taxable ₹2,75,000).

Summary of the scenarios

#

Mistake

Correct position (tax year 2025-26)

1

HRA while in government quarters

Only months with rent actually paid

2

₹42,500 Siachen limit

₹7,000 a month, old regime

3

Field area plus border area

One or the other

4

MSP, group pay, flying pay as exempt

Taxable salary

5

Service allowances in the new regime

Taxable, except travel, daily charges, conveyance, disabled transport

6

Disability pension without the record

Exempt only with the conditions and documents

7

Agniveer double deduction

Government share in salary, then 80CCH(2); own share once, 80CCH(1), old regime

8

80C for an unpaid premium

Only sums paid in the year

9

Leave encashed while serving

Taxable

10

Pension left out after re-employment

Both incomes, one standard deduction

11

Family pension under 10(19) without operational death

Other sources, less one-third or ₹15,000 / ₹25,000

How to claim correctly

Keep these for at least as long as the department can reopen the year:

  • Pay slips for every month and the posting orders showing where you served: place-based limits depend on the area and the months.
  • Rent agreement, receipts and bank transfers for every HRA month.
  • The pension payment order and the release or invaliding medical board record for a disability pension. For the tax year 2026-27 rule, the record should show that you were invalided out, and that the disability was attributable to or aggravated by service.
  • The certificate from the Head of Department or service headquarters for a family pension claimed under section 10(19).
  • Receipts for every deduction, dated in the year you claim it.
  • Your Form 16 and pay slips side by side with Form 26AS/AIS, so that the salary, pension and tax deducted in your return match the department's records.

Checklist before you file

  1. Decide the regime first; most exemptions here are old-regime only.
  2. For each exempt allowance, name its Rule 2BB row, check the monthly limit and count the months.
  3. Do not combine field area with border/disturbed area, or counter-insurgency with disturbed area.
  4. Use 2025-26 limits, not the Rules 2026 figures.
  5. Include every salary and pension, with one standard deduction.
  6. Agniveers: add the Government contribution to salary before deducting it.

Related guides: Army personnel: tax exemptions and deductions, Navy personnel, Air Force personnel, retiring Army personnel, retiring Navy personnel, retiring Air Force personnel and Agniveer income tax and Seva Nidhi. To compare regimes with your own figures, try the income tax calculator.

How TaxCare helps

TaxCare's filing flow compares both regimes with your own figures, and nothing is submitted until you approve the return. If a claim is unclear, or you have received a notice, a Tax Expert can help.

This guide gives general information and is not legal or professional tax advice.

Questions on this topic

I claimed the ₹42,500 Siachen limit in my return for tax year 2025-26. What should I do?

For tax year 2025-26 the exempt limit is ₹7,000 a month under Rule 2BB, and only in the old regime. The ₹42,500 figure is in the Income-tax Rules, 2026, for tax year 2026-27 onward. File a revised return before 31-Mar-2027, or an updated return (ITR-U) after that, and pay the extra tax with interest.

Will I get a penalty for a mistake I made in good faith?

An adjustment made while your return is processed is not by itself a penalty. A penalty for under-reporting can follow an assessment, but no penalty is levied where the explanation is accepted as bona fide and all material facts were disclosed (section 439(8) of the Income-tax Act, 2025; the same rule is reported under section 270A of the 1961 Act). Correcting the return yourself early is the safest step.

Are flying, sea-going, submarine or MSP payments exempt?

No. They are not named in Rule 2BB (or in rule 280 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026), so they are taxable salary. Only allowances named in the rules are exempt, each up to its own limit.

Can an Agniveer claim section 80CCH in the new regime?

Only section 80CCH(2), the deduction for the Government's contribution, which is first added to salary. The deduction for the Agniveer's own contribution, section 80CCH(1), is allowed in the old regime only.

Does filing an updated return (ITR-U) protect me from a penalty?

From 1-Mar-2026, income on which the ITR-U additional tax is paid cannot be the basis of a penalty under section 270A. An ITR-U cannot reduce tax or increase a refund, and it costs an additional 25% to 70% of the tax and interest, depending on when it is filed.

Ready to file your ITR?

TaxCare fetches your AIS and TDS from the Income Tax portal, checks every figure and files the return that saves you the most. 25% off your first filing.